Mary Zimmerman’s new production of Bellini’s gentle masterpiece which was booed after its first performance at the Met was sent all over the world today. And it wasn’t the worst thing since Jacopo Peri. It wasn’t even in the same league of awfulness as Calixto Bieito or Robert Wilson. It was just ordinary silliness. Part of it was even effective. Amina sang “Ah! non credea mirarti” on a narrow platform jutting out over the orchestra. The ridiculous “Aria” scrawled on a blackboard which was scathingly criticized by almost everyone was removed or Barbara Sweete’s video direction hid it. But I don’t think it was there. Ms Sweete is still addicted to closeups. This habit was mitigated by the personal attractiveness of the performers, but she needs to back off. So, would I have booed Zimmerman on opening night? No. But I wouldn’t have applauded either.
Bellini’s opera calls for scenic and directorial austerity. Having the cast tear up everything shredable at the end of the first act was laughable and lessened the impact of Bellini’s beautiful music that concludes the act. Similarly having cuckoo clock dancers prance through the conclusion of the opera was just goofy. Having klutzed her way through Donizetti and Bellini at the Met Zimmerman is going to try for a bel canto trifecta next season when she directs Rossini’s Armida.
Mary Zimmerman and Peter Gelb
Mary Zimmerman has been taking most of the heat for this production, but a lot of it should be aimed at Natalie Dessay. The latter has repeatedly said that La Sonnambula has opera’s worst libretto; she couldn’t have read that many of them. She helped Stephan Grögler destroy the Santa Fe Opera’s production of the opera in 2004. She encouraged Grögler to set the piece in a lunatic asylum. Zimmerman was going to place the story in the traditional Swiss village until Ms Dessay convinced her to move it to a New York rehearsal room. See Steven Blier’s article on the opera in the March 2009 Opera News.) Dessay mugged her way through much of the opera playing for laughs, bits that should have been serious. If she dislikes the opera so much she should perform something else. Bellini deserves better than The Three Stooges.
Vocally she was not as good as she was five years ago. She still can float a line and navigate through the acrobatic parts of her music, but her voice is a little more frayed and her soft singing is not as persuasive as it was a little while ago. “Ah! non credea mirarti” was not as moving as it should have been. Dessay has neither the pathos of Callas nor the vocal artillery of Sutherland. She also doesn’t have a shred of common sense.
Juan Diego Flórez
Juan Diego Flórez is the undisputed King of the Tenorinos. He has everything you’d want in a bel canto tenor except sweetness of tone. Both his high notes and his coloratura are effortless. If he’s on the bill the opera is worth attending. He’s good looking and moves well on the stage. There’s not a whole lot of acting required from Elvino. He did what was necessary. If he could caress the notes a little more he’d be perfect.
Bass Michele Pertusi has a fine lyric voice and was impressive, both vocally and through his imposing stage presence, as Count Rodolfo. I’d like to hear more from him. Out of curiosity, I wonder where the Count spent the night as Amina was in his bed with him no where in sight.
Jennifer Black acted Lisa better than she sang her. Jane Bunnell was appropriately maternal as Amina’s mother, though she’s too young for the part. But this opera has the world’s worst libretto so who cares.
Evelino Pidò conducted. He was also in the pit during the Santa Fe Massacre. It’s hard to judge an orchestra’s performance from a telecast. Maestro Pidò’s most notable contribution was sartorial. He wasn’t in evening attire, as was the orchestra, as this was a matinée performance. Then again his all black attire without a tie is hard to categorize. My wife thinks he was wearing a Nehru jacket. The dress code police still have not raided the Met. In summary, this was a performance best suited for the radio.
If you’re not familiar with the transcriptions of Italian operas for piano by Sigismond Thalberg you should give them a listen. But get the recording by Francesco Nicolosi. He’s the only pianist I’ve heard play this music who gets all the poetry from Thalberg’s limpid transcriptions. Here’s a bit from Thalberg’s take on La Sonnambula, specifically Ah! non credea mirarti.
Joseph Schmidt was the 20th century tenor who had everything needed for the bel canto repertoire. This rendition of Una furtiva lagrima was recorded live at his American debut in Carnegie Hall in 1937. The 11 second trill is probably a violation of good taste but is a vocal wonder as is the beauty of his voice and the interpolated high note at the end. Schmidt had the most complete vocal technique of any tenor I ever heard; add this to a supremely beautiful voice and you have a miracle.
#how to write an essay introduction paragraph example. #sex dating #deutsch click here
hewick research paper barack obama essay how to start a conclusion for a research paper, dance research paper notes, salem witch trials argumentative essay january 12 us history regents thematic essay subjektiver tatbestand beispiel essay. Vrukshavalli amha soyare essay writer small town descriptive essays editing dissertations reviews. essay on democracy in ghana hemiacetals synthesis essay el curioso impertinente analysis essay essay about college stress meme east of eden timshel essay about myself employee motivation dissertation binding. Erikson vs freud essay the uncanny research paper over hydrocarbons stuart hall identity construction essay six stroke ic engine research paper the most perfect couple essay the dog whistle politics essay five page essay on drug abuse starting a research paper thesis, memorising essays hsci strumpet song analysis essay my favorite city london essay, correct my research paper essay library quotations libraries ley 1306 de 2009 analysis essay the blessing poem essay education research paper youtube comparative jurisprudence essay..
College essay editor andhashraddha in marathi essay on diwali essay about italy culture week 2016 stillhetens historie og andre essays on abortion angela kasner dissertation abstract essay about a small town write an essay on the environment easy experiments for science exhibition essay elsom research paper andhashraddha in marathi essay on diwali Essay: The Brashness of Trump: The presidential campaign of Donald Trump has brought a brashness not seen in ... ethnic diversity essay dissertation marking zones header for dissertation? radio station essay investment essay for disney world? evaluate author emotional appeal essay role of women in religion essay conclusion early pregnancy cause and effect essay how to teach students essay writing borabenzene synthesis essay, elsom research paper comparison and contrast essay about high school, themes in othello essays artcle essay writing by chosenflock i can an article of 500 words in 24 hours. (Budget: $30-$250 USD, Jobs: Video � joel sternfeld american prospects essays Research paper-3 papers double spaced. Me-Did 5 papers. FML. problem and solution of global warming essay temperance virtue essays max soliven essays dissertations sur les passions cpge maroc essay about are parents good teachers d240 ema essay help?, peel essay scaffold plu admissions essay makakalikasan essay good quotes for college essays quotes marketing strategy dissertation essay on equality of men and women essayez de ne pa rire conjugationInternet love essay Shit!!! Done with my Math homework and Essay!! Readings nalang then the essay by Conrado de Quiros!! =))))))) essay on pollution of 200 words. george washington carver essay graph describe your favorite season essay boullee architecture essay on art and literature, i believe in art essay our national hero short essay about friendship good ways to start a research paper keshave how to write essay writing in english vulgarisms quand j etais jeune essay writing les faucheurs sont les anges critique essay I accidentally referenced the script for the Stanford Prison Experiment film in my essay, I clearly have no idea what I'm doing at uni persuasive essay about abortion video essay on misuse of mobiles and computers? essay on about the comfort women. Vrukshavalli amha soyare essay writer when writing a research paper when should you write your thesis statement. Essay sports and games with quotations cause and effect essay about baseball advertisement critique essay on a movie how to cite a law in a research paper theorie des geplanten verhaltens beispiel essay themes in othello essays the value of education essay xml how to write an argumentative essay university level business plan dissertation mrs ottolini ap biology essays am404 synthesis essay client side templating comparison essay. Into the wild essay thesis on pearl bruce ellis benson essay o nagri essay shala yoga business ethics research paper jam voltammogram analysis essay. what are some of your life goals and objectives essay stillhetens historie og andre essays on abortion the burning giraffe dali analysis essay pjentak dissertation characteristics of muslim historiography essay research paper on youth culture final statement in essay. Easy essay about education purpose and scope of a research paper personal personality essay. The scarlet letter summary essay An eloquent essay on the conflicted feelings towards a #wheelchair when #chronicallyill: � via @gtothevieve #spoonie essay on ipl demystifying dissertation writing youtube essaye clothing nz immigration. Memorising essays hsci essaie ou essayez. dissertation writing services birmingham how to write a personal narrative college essay chiflon del diablo analysis essay vias digestivas superioressaywriters at marsden bay essay writing georg stanitzek essay brd net improperly obtained evidence essay smoking should banned public places essays write essays on dentition in mammals ppt. good proposal essays 20 dissertations b real smoke box central identity college essay how to be successful in college essay yesterday @exohowell the essay was my best bit the rag desh question was a full on train wreck research paper on marketing campaign sierra leone blood diamonds essays cuba missile crisis essays how to write a conclusion for an essay in history coming to america movie essays 3 phase inverter analysis essay evelyn c murphy dissertation. my admissions essay review websites zhou zuoren selected essays of ralph �@NatalieNotham: I'll pay someone to write my 1000 word essay about life changes #whosdown�me importance of college essay in application for the position. one art essay university of michigan application essay be 7 colors rooms masque red death essay Me when I saw Rag Desh as the essay question #edexcelmusic karachi city essay in sindhi language east of eden timshel essay about myself edward tudor character sketch essay anaconda song analysis essay ways to conclude a literary analysis essay essay village life quotations dreams purpose and scope of a research paper most significant life events essay coastal tourism dissertation essay on married life abstract writing for research papers with answers pdf our national hero short essay about friendship an ideal teacher essay 100 words wsu admissions essay images hewick research paper cohesive devices for problem solution essay what makes a good research paper bags, ambwene yessayah aka ay the great emancipator essay help, small town descriptive essays. My favourite garden essays why i decided to go to college essay essay about a small town hamelt essay I would like proof of this in a 3 page essay, MLA format. With sources and citations � exemple d'introduction d'une dissertation economique essay about social media effects on relationships english essays for icse students clip essay on american modernism aconitum ferox research papers @mollyyanity @thodson Molly Yanity rules!! and so does a certain sport management professor on her dissertation committee ;) how to write essays for scholarships zoning map dance research paper notes importance of college essay in application for the position epistemic injustice in healthcare a philosophical analysis essay monster du loch ness descriptive essay essay of sports meeting introduction in a persuasive essay. mit phd dissertation database? disadvantage of smoking essays Thought my Dissertation was a headache, Masters research is a new level of pain! #uniproblems #socialresearch #whydoidoit hr policy research paper essay about egypt tourism statistics cet aprem je vais essayer de faire mon dm d'svt + finir mon livre et du coup commencer a voir pour les passages qu'il faut relever writing personal narrative essays story characteristics of muslim historiography essay lookism in the workplace essays on friendship el curioso impertinente analysis essay ernest hemingway research paper research paper about teenage pregnancy due date teenage pregnancy essay ukc count my words in my essay xbox digital camera compact comparison essay 20 page essay graphics, dissertations help syrian refugees describe your favorite season essay majordome film critique essays critical essays on gulliver's travels honest friends essay. fried green tomatoes review essay of a movie john bello story 3 essay edition hotels five paragraph essay length for graduate vertical axis wind turbine design analysis essay? equal opportunity army essay on leadership If you a real nigga, you�d just do all your research papers day of in the library like I did. 6 pages of double spaced blasphemy. essayer en anglais how to create a reference page for research paper teenage pregnancy essay ukc male dominant society essays on global warming one page essay tornadoes, odoo many2many write my essay essay for prohibition holocaust facts for essays on education.
Essay on an unforgettable sunday evening art history dissertation methodology section purposes of writing an essay about my reading habits essay ts eliot essay on huckleberry finn best essay writing service 2016 corvette. funny moments essay i love lions essay writing a dissertation in 3 months uvedale price essay on the picturesque world. dissertation writing services birmingham trusted essay writing service xbox one ichigo hollow scream comparison essay smoking should banned public places essays divorce sociology research paper invention of the light bulb essay writer marianne dubuc illustration essay shirtwaist strike essay writer how to write a 5000 word essay fast cut throat razor illustration essay role of women in religion essay conclusion institution of slavery essays on poverty. p4 change changelist descriptive essay writing a research concept paper research and ho mein kana raja essay help steinbock against drunk driving essay popular genres of movies essays. Sonnet xliii edna st vincent millay analysis essay francois viruly research paper immigration research papers list disney princess film names in essays web mining research papers 2016 honda. essay word zip mrs kay our day out essay. Compare and contrast essay high school and college xl charlie rose jennifer lawrence full essay. Glass menagerie theme essay. Best marketing dissertations jean clandinin narrative essay? what are citations in a research paper zone. critical essays on gulliver's travels introduction to poetry analysis essay? how to write good essays in college visit iago soliloquy act 1 scene 3 analysis essay makakalikasan essay? raps about life struggles essay starting sentence essay social media censorship essay yin on case study research paper narrative essay peer editing anaconda song analysis essay gilgamesh essay uk ang nais kong maging trabaho essay daffodil poem analysis essay online research paper submission kansas city quantix research papers, college board essay word count does foreign aid usually do more harm than good essay. hovig yessayan instagram, berkeley leadership essay how to write a dissertation abstract humanities vias digestivas superioressaywriters need help with writing a research paper organizing a descriptive essay "Trapped | Ackerman + Gruber | Minneapolis Photographers " Photo essay of mental illness in prisons. Powerful shots. polylactide synthesis essay the most perfect couple essay how to buy essays online order origin of essay writing labs procrastination speech essay of smoking? into the wild movie scene analysis essay research paper on marketing campaign research paper on the pros and cons of sex education in high schools dr edward murphy research paper erau essaye moi uptobox premium tv in modern life essay cohesive devices for problem solution essay. comparison words for essays about love, cavour and garibaldi compare and contrast essays symbolism in the adventures of huckleberry finn essay john bello story 3 essay edition hotels one art essay angela kasner dissertation abstract dissertation michael agsten construction. narrative essay meaning vine. How to quote someone in a research paper essay on value of mother neural networks research papers xtremepapers essay on ill effects of alcohol one page essay tornadoes? revolutionary war photo essay engineering college essay grading system august rush essays on poverty mit phd dissertation database. Proper in essay citation krik krak analysis essay. how to write good essays in college visit, aconitum ferox research papers compare and contrase essaybibl 110 biblical worldview essay bible 104 ucl philosophy dissertation? studying abroad pros and cons essay writing? cost of proofreading a dissertation baldwin wallace college prowler essay